The present research entitled "the Isra'iliyyat of the story of Mary and Jesus (p.b.u.t) in Shia and Sunny commentaries, with emphasis on Behar al-Anwar" was conducted with the aim of extracting the Isra'iliyyat of Behar al-Anwar in narrating the stories of Mary and Jesus. It is mainly aimed at extracting the Isra'iliyyat of these stories and elaborating on how Allamah Majlesi addressed these narratives and their narrators by studying the text of the Behar al-Anwar, reviewing Allamah's other works and comparing and contrasting them with Shia and Sunny commentaries. Some scholars, including Allamah Tabatabaii and Allamah Askari, believe that Majlesi had not tried to select valid narratives and differentiate them from weak ones and had only gathered all valid and invalid hadiths in Behar al-Anwar without considering their validity or invalidity in relation to infallible Imams, while the analysis of his "remarks" and explanations under the aforementioned narratives and comparing them with other commentaries show that general public's conception contradicts with how Majlesi had really addressed these narratives. In other words, it should be said that only few Isra'iliyyat can be found among many related narratives, which are explicitly rejected by Majlesi or can be invalidated on the basis of Majlesi's other criteria for other narratives, because there are many instances of his explicit and clear rejection of Isra'iliyyat and their narrators in all parts of Behar al-Anwar. Therefore, it should be said that Allamah Majlesi had carefully selected the narrations on the basis of his specific criteria and had thus prevented the entrance of many Isra'iliyyat into Behar al-Anwar as a complete collection of hadiths. So, it can be concluded that attention to Isra'iliyyat, their narrators and explicit and clear rejection of such narratives is one of the Majlesi's important criteria for selecting narratives for Behar al-Anwar. Seyyedeh Vahideh Rahimi[1]
Faezeh Sadat Khosravi[2]
[1] Assistant professor of Qom University
[2] MA of sciences of the Quran and hadith
Date Received: 2015/10/26, Date of acceptance: 2016/1/6
ابن کثیر، اسماعیل ابن عمر؛ البدایه و النهایه؛ چاپ دوم، بیروت: دارالکتب العلمیه، 1408 ق.
ــــــــــــــــــــــ ؛ تفسیر القرآن العظیم؛ تحقیق محمد حسین شمس الدین، چاپ اول، بیروت: دارالکتب العلمیه (منشورات محمدعلى بیضون)، 1419 ق.
ابوریه، محمود؛ اضواء علی السنة المحمدیه؛ چاپ پنجم، بی جا: دارالکتاب الاسلامی، بی تا.
ابوشهبه، محمدبن محمد؛ الاسرائیلیات و الموضوعات فی کتب التفسیر؛ چاپ اول، بیروت: دارالجیل، 1413ق.
ابوعزیز، سعد یوسف؛ الاسرائیلیات والموضوعات فی کتب التفاسیر قدیما و حدیثا؛ قاهره: مکتبه التوفیقیه، بی تا.
امین، احمد؛ فجرالاسلام؛ چاپ دهم، بیروت: دارالکتاب العربی، 1969م.
جمعی از نویسندگان؛ دایرة المعارف بزرگ اسلامی؛ زیرنظرکاظم موسوی بجنوردی، چاپ دوم، تهران: مرکز دایرة المعارف بزرگ اسلامی، 1369ش.
جمعی از نویسندگان؛دایرة المعارف تشیع؛ زیر نظر احمد صدر حاج سید جوادی، کامران فانی و بهاء الدین خرمشاهی، چاپ دوم، تهران: بنیاد خیریه و فرهنگی شط، 1372ش.
حائری، ابوعلی محمّدبن اسماعیل مازندرانی؛ منتهی المقال فی احوال الرّجال؛ چاپ اوّل، قم: مؤسّسة آل البیت(ع) لاحیاء التراث، ١۴١۶ ق.
ذهبی، ابوعبدالله شمس الدین؛ تذکرة الحفاظ؛ چاپ اول، بیروت: داراحیاء التراث العربی، 1374ق.
ذهبی، محمدبن احمدبن عثمان؛ سیر اعلام النبلاء؛ تحقیق نعیم العرقسوسی و مأمون صاغرجی، چاپ نهم، بیروت: موسسه رساله، 1413 ق.
ذهبی، محمد حسین؛ الاسرائیلیات فی التفسیر و الحدیث؛ چاپ دوم، دمشق: دارالایمان، 1405 ق.
ــــــــــــــــــ ؛ التفسیر و المفسرون؛ بیروت: داراحیاء التراث العربی، بی تا.
زمخشری، محمود؛ الکشاف عن حقائق غوامض التنزیل؛ چاپ سوم، بیروت: دارالکتاب العربی، 1407 ق.
سیوطی، جلال الدین؛ الاتقان فی علوم القرآن؛ باتحقیق محمّد ابوالفضل ابراهیم، قم: منشورات الشریف الرّضی، بی تا.
khosravi, F. S. (2015). The Isra'iliyyat (of the Israelites) of the Story of Mary and Jesus (p.b.u.t) in Shia and Sunny Commentaries, with Emphasis on Behar al- Anwar (Seas of Lights). Comparative Interpretation Research, 1(2), 109-132. doi: 10.22091/ptt.2015.589
MLA
faeze Sadat khosravi. "The Isra'iliyyat (of the Israelites) of the Story of Mary and Jesus (p.b.u.t) in Shia and Sunny Commentaries, with Emphasis on Behar al- Anwar (Seas of Lights)". Comparative Interpretation Research, 1, 2, 2015, 109-132. doi: 10.22091/ptt.2015.589
HARVARD
khosravi, F. S. (2015). 'The Isra'iliyyat (of the Israelites) of the Story of Mary and Jesus (p.b.u.t) in Shia and Sunny Commentaries, with Emphasis on Behar al- Anwar (Seas of Lights)', Comparative Interpretation Research, 1(2), pp. 109-132. doi: 10.22091/ptt.2015.589
VANCOUVER
khosravi, F. S. The Isra'iliyyat (of the Israelites) of the Story of Mary and Jesus (p.b.u.t) in Shia and Sunny Commentaries, with Emphasis on Behar al- Anwar (Seas of Lights). Comparative Interpretation Research, 2015; 1(2): 109-132. doi: 10.22091/ptt.2015.589
)
Send comment about this article